Shoe Cream Vs Polish - What Should You Choose?

shoe cream vs shoe polish what's the difference, the ultimate guide

When it comes to maintaining the longevity and appearance of leather shoes, the choice between shoe cream and shoe polish can be puzzling. These two products, often confused, have distinct uses and effects on your footwear, which is why it is vital to understand the exact match between shoe requirements and appropriate care methods. 

Let's talk about the differences between cream polish and shoe polish, to ensure you choose the right product for your leather shoes and keep them in their prime for years to come.

What's the Difference Between Shoe Polish and Shoe Cream?

Shoe polish, primarily a wax-based product, is the go-to choice for providing a high-gloss, shiny finish that is highly sought after in the world of shoe shine. On the other hand, shoe cream is a hybrid formulation containing both wax and oil designed to deeply penetrate the leather.

This replenishes and preserves the natural oils, keeping your fine leather shoes soft and supple, and staving off cracks. The shoe polish vs cream debate often boils down to whether shine or nourishment is your priority.

Furthermore, considerations extend to the presence of dye in both cream and wax products, a crucial factor in maintaining or altering the color of your footwear. But, the story doesn't end here.

Let's talk about some specific differences between cream polish and shoe polish to help you make an informed decision.


Shoe cream has a creamier texture, created from oils and conditioners, while shoe polish is a blend of wax, colorants, and solvents. The choice between the two depends on what you aim to achieve.

For instance, if you desire a more natural finish or color restoration, shoe cream would be your go-to product.

However, if you're seeking a glossy finish and stronger protection, shoe polish would be more suitable. It's essential to remember that shoe cream and shoe polish serve different purposes, and using them in conjunction may provide the most beneficial results for your leather shoes.


Another key difference between shoe cream and shoe polish is the color options available. While shoe polish comes in a wide range of shades, including bright colors, shoe cream is typically only available in neutral hues like black, brown, and neutral.

If you want to add some pop of color to your shoes, then shoe polish would be the better choice. However, if you prefer a more subtle and classic look, shoe cream would be the ideal option.


The finish achieved with shoe polish is a glossy shine, while shoe cream gives a more natural matte finish. This difference is due to the varying ingredients used in both products. Shoe polish contains wax that creates a shiny layer on top of the leather, while shoe cream absorbs into the leather, resulting in a more natural look.

So, if you want a bright and glossy finish for your shoes, shoe polish is the way to go. On the other hand, if you prefer a more understated and casual appearance, shoe cream would be the right choice.


The application process for shoe polish and shoe cream also differs. Shoe polish is typically applied with a cloth or brush, and then buffed to a shine after drying. In contrast, shoe cream is dabbed onto the leather with a finger or cloth and immediately buffed into it.

The choice between the two products may depend on your personal preference and the time you have available for shoe maintenance. However, keep in mind that proper application techniques are crucial for achieving the desired results.


Both shoe cream and shoe polish help protect leather shoes from liquids and stains, but shoe polish typically offers a more robust and long-lasting defense. If you live in a wet or snowy climate, it may be beneficial to use shoe polish for added protection against the elements.

Ultimately, the best choice between shoe cream and shoe polish depends on your personal preferences and the specific needs of your shoes. If you want a shiny finish and extra protection, go for shoe polish; if you prefer a natural look or don't need as much protection, shoe cream would be the better option.

Remember to always follow the recommended application and usage guidelines provided by the manufacturer, regardless of which product you choose.

Which One is Best for You?

There's no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to the choice between regular shoe polish vs cream shoe polish. This decision depends on several factors such as the type of shoes you own, the finish you desire, the surface of the shoe, and the level of protection you need.

Brands like Stone and Clark and Saphir offer a variety of products to cater to different preferences. For instance, if you're seeking a high-gloss, durable finish for your dress shoes, a wax shoe polish or hard wax might be the best fit. It imparts a layer of shine on the shoe surface, creating an impressive finish that's particularly suited for formal or special occasions.

On the other hand, if you're more focused on maintaining the shoe's health and longevity, a cream shoe polish would serve better. Its oil content helps replenish the leather's natural oils, keeping it supple and preventing cracks. The pigment in cream polish can also aid in restoring or enhancing the shoe's color.

Of course, for comprehensive shoe care, using both wax and cream polish in an appropriate sequence is recommended. The key lies in understanding your shoe's needs and using the right polish accordingly.

Whether you opt for a cream or wax polish, remember to follow the manufacturers' instructions to maximize benefits.

Stone and Clark's Shoe Shine Kit

You might want to check out Stone and Clark's 12PC Shoe Polish & Care Kit, which includes different shades of shoe cream and shoe polish, along with essential tools for shoe maintenance. This kit is suitable for both men and women and is designed to keep your leather shoes looking polished and new.

Get yours here!

Tips When Using Shoe Cream and Shoe Polish

To help you with using the right polish for your fine leather shoes, here are some tips:

  • Identify the needs of your shoes: Different types of shoes require different types of care. For a pair of shoes that you wear frequently, you may need to use a cream polish regularly to nourish the leather and maintain its color.
  • Consider your shoe color: The color of your shoes plays a crucial role in selecting a suitable shoe polish. Always try to match the polish color as closely as possible to the color of your shoes to maintain their original look.
  • Use leather conditioner: To further nourish the leather, you can also use a leather conditioner before applying the polish. This helps to keep the leather flexible and reduces the appearance of cracks or scuffs.
  • Apply in layers: For a high shine, apply a layer of wax on top of the cream polish. The high concentration of wax in the shoe polish will give your shoes a mirror shine.
  • Address scuffs promptly: Whenever you notice a scuff on your pair of shoes, address it immediately with the correct color shoe cream or polish to prevent it from becoming more noticeable over time.
  • Polish regularly: Regular polishing not only keeps your shoes looking good, but also extends their lifespan by providing a protective layer against dirt, moisture, and general wear and tear.

Closing Thoughts

Knowing what shoe care products to use and how to use them correctly is crucial for keeping your leather shoes looking their best. Whether you choose shoe cream or shoe polish, regular cleaning and conditioning will help maintain the appearance and longevity of your footwear.

So, next time you're faced with choosing between shoe cream and shoe polish, consider the composition, color options, finish, application method, and protection levels of each product to make the best decision for your leather shoes.

Make sure to check out Stone and Clark's Amazon store for quality leather care products to help you keep your shoes looking impeccable. Our must-have horsehair brush will also help you achieve the perfect shine every time you use shoe polish or cream.

12PC Leather Shoe Shine & Care Kit for Men & Women

3.5 oz Mink Oil Leather Care Kit with Applicator

Subscribe Us
Subscribe to our newsletter and receive a selection of cool articles every weeks