How to Choose the Right Shoe Polish -  A Comprehensive Guide

How to Choose the Right Shoe Polish

If you own leather shoes, one essential product to include in your shoe care and maintenance kit is quality shoe polish. The right polish not only preserves the look of your footwear but can also extend its lifespan significantly.

The pigment is a crucial factor since leather shoes can come in different colors, and selecting a matching polish will ensure your dress shoes always look their best. Shoe cream, in particular, is favored for its ability to nourish the leather while providing color rejuvenation, keeping your cherished footwear in pristine condition.

Here's a comprehensive guide on how to choose the right shoe polish.

Step 1: Determine Shoe Material

determine the shoe material

First and foremost, identify the material your shoes are made of. Leather is the most common material in need of polish, but there are different products for suede, nubuck, patent leather, and synthetic materials.

Using a pommadier cream shoe polish for full-grain leather shoes can be advantageous, as it conditions and imparts a rich color. For materials like suede and nubuck, however, you would need a dedicated product designed for the textural complexity of these fabrics.

Using the wrong polish can damage the material, so this step is imperative to the health and longevity of your footwear.

Step 2: Consider Shoe Polish Colour

When considering shoe polish color, aim to pick a shade that corresponds closely to your leather shoes. For example, with shades of brown ranging from light brown shoes to mahogany brown and dark brown, it's essential to choose a brown shoe polish that complements the specific tone.

A medium brown polish is versatile but, if in doubt, select a color that is slightly darker than your shoes as it's more forgiving. Remember, you don't want to change the color of your original hue.

For those with shoes in tobacco brown or other intricate colors, go for a neutral cream. This will maintain the natural patina of your footwear while still providing a polished look.

Remember, shoe polish will almost never exactly match the original color, but by selecting a close shade, you can achieve a natural and uniform finish. 

Step 3: Choose the Right Polish Type

Choose the Right Polish Type

In general, there are three primary types of shoe polish aside from the colour of your shoes: shoe cream, wax, and liquid polishes, each designed with specific benefits in mind.

  1. Shoe cream penetrates deeply into the leather, providing essential moisturization that keeps your shoes supple.
  2. For those who possess a classic black shoe or shoes in any color that requires a high-gloss finish, a wax polish will be ideal as it offers a higher shine and layers on a protective coating to guard against moisture and dirt.
  3. Meanwhile, liquid polish actually serves as a rapid solution for fast touch-ups, proving convenient for those on-the-go situations where time is of the essence.

Selecting the right type involves balancing your need for protection and desired shine level.

Read related article: Shoe Cream Vs Polish - What Should You Choose?

Step 4: Assess Polish Ingredients

While not being prioritized by many, scrutinizing the ingredients list on shoe cream and wax products can significantly impact the health of your leather footwear.

Many shoe cream and wax products boast a mixture of natural waxes and oils which play a pivotal role in nourishing and maintaining the leather's suppleness.

On the other hand, be cautious of polishes laden with an excess of harsh chemicals. Such compounds have the potential to desiccate the leather over time, leading to unsightly cracks and damage.

For a simple rule of thumb, the more natural the ingredient list, the gentler and more beneficial the polish will be for your shoes' longevity.

Tips for Keeping Your Shoes Polished

black horsehair brush

Get your premium black horsehair brush here!

To further enhance the longevity and sheen of your leather shoes, consider these extra tips:

  • Use a soft cloth to apply polish in circular motions for an even distribution.
  • Wipe off excess polish and buff with a brush or shoe shine cloth.
  • Use a horsehair brush to buff your shoes for a high shine.
  • Allow the polish to dry completely before wearing or storing your shoes.
  • Regularly clean the surface of your shoes from dirt and debris before polishing.
  • Polish in a well-ventilated area, as shoe polish can produce strong fumes.
  • Avoid using too much polish, as this can cause buildup and damage to the leather.

Read related article: How to Polish Shoes - A Detailed Guide to Shine Your Shoes

Closing Thoughts

In summary, choosing the right shoe polish is crucial for maintaining and extending the lifespan of your leather shoes. By considering factors such as material, color, type, and ingredients, you can select a high-quality polish that keeps your footwear looking its best for years to come.

Remember to also follow proper polishing techniques and maintenance tips to ensure your beloved shoes remain in pristine condition.

shoe shine kit

Make sure to check out Stone and Clark's Shoe Shine Kit, which includes all the essentials for keeping your leather shoes polished and well-maintained.

12PC Leather Shoe Shine & Care Kit for Men & Women

3.5 oz Mink Oil Leather Care Kit with Applicator

Subscribe Us
Subscribe to our newsletter and receive a selection of cool articles every weeks